ThePigeonMaster's movie Reviews on Newgrounds

[Super Mario World on Crak]

You have a lot of potential as a sprite animator

But man, if you use Mario, please be all the original as possible. You're not the first that use the song "chacarron macarron" and Mario dancing like a retard. Or maybe you just made that just for fun, which is OK but it doesn't guarantees you a perfect score in most cases :/
Some of the skits were TOO random and some of them didn't make sense at all, I mean, a shy guy that fires up then dies then fires up again. It would have been funny if it had a plot on why the shy guy was in fire. Returning on the chacarron macarron, the last part of the movie when mario is WTF and then dances like a retard again, THAT made me LOL. And when Mario was in underpants dancing again, haha.
The animation was decent but please, use a higher FPS, use minimum 25.
Conclusion: It was OK
7/10
3/5

Voting details:
Voting power: 6.64
Voter number: Voted while judging, no info available.
Voted 5: Voted while judging, no info available.

Note: I still liked this, don't think I disliked the flash just because I pointed you the bad things of it. And that's what I call Constructive criticism.

***Pigeonmaster88***

[Corky52's Birthday Collab]

I like all birthday flashes

No matter how they look, they always get my 10 and 5.
The pac-man skit was hilarious in my opinion, specially because he was eating like a statwhore XD
The part from MinusNick was... weird. But well, a nice detail to a statwhore XD lol
And we finally have the part from FamilyGuy05, i liked it because there can't be a birthday without that song. It's like eating a burger without meat.
Overall the quality wasn't bad and the skits were nicely animated :)
Conclusion: Corey, have a happy birthday ;)
10/10
5/5

Voting details:
Voting power: 6.63
Voter number: 23
Voted 5: Voted while judging, no info available.

Note: Too bad that YoungAndWise and Murad136 didn't participate in this, but at least they tried to congratulate him, which is what counts here.

***Pigeonmaster88***

Sispri responds:

Yay, thanks for the review, dude.

[sprite or not to sprite?]

To sprite or not to sprite?

Depends of the animator. That is the answer.
I thought you were going to move into greater things since we were making Skittles n' dickz, to be honest. But I'm not crying or sad or something haha, in fact, It's great to see talented animators moving into greater things!
As for the flash, the concept was very good, and the part where you were turned from sprites into a drawing was excellent. And the music fit very good on what was happening.
Conclusion: Detailed, well animated, well drawn (including the custom sprites of yourself).
10/10
5/5

Voting details:
Voting power: 6.63
Voter number: 411
Voted 5: 3.78 / 5.00 (+ 0.0065)

Note: You know something? The answer of why sprites are declining is simple:
LAME ANIMATORS. I'm currently seeing like 3 sprite animations in the flash portal made from noobs trying to be like Randy, bigfoot and psycosis. But those little ignorants don't know they're making it WORSE. I wish I could get rid of those pieces of trash >:(

Note 2: LOL to JonBro.

Note 3: A question, Are you thinking in making a videogame parody, but made with drawings? :3

***Pigeonmaster88***

Emanhattan responds:

hey dude. You are right. there are some no0bs around. but I think its cool. We all started as no0bs right? right?

anyway thanks for the 10. yes I plan to make a few videogame parodies but Ive been thinking of starting my own series or somehting soon!

D thanks mate! you keep making sprites THE RIGHT WAY

[Disturbing Tails in 1 min]

You know?

I liked this :)
Specially because you got inspired from me and my flash god bigfoot3290.
The animation of the sprites was smooth, the only detail that I could say, was the sound. The sound it screwed up sometimes, try to get better sound files with better qualities, that's all.
Conclusion: Nice work :)
10/10
5/5

Voting details:
Voting power: 6.82
Voter number: 219
Voted 5: 2.97 / 5.00 (+ 0.039)

Note: Keep up the good work :)

***Pigeonmaster88***

FireBlazeProductions responds:

Thanks man. I wish you luck with your next flash. Also, I keep up my skills and try to come up with some funny stuff.

peace.

[Luigi's Fear]

Mmm... Not bad for a 1st attempt at sprite movies

The fact of using luigi being scared of things has been used many times.
As for the animation, it was very well for a 1st attempt, Have you used flash before or something? It looks neat for a 1st movie ;)
Conclusion: Nice for a 1st attempt!
7/10
4/5

Voting details:
Voting power: 6.61
Voter number: 249
Voted 4: 3.17 / 5.00 (+ 0.026)

Note: Too bad you only got the trial =(

***Pigeonmaster88***

Sandling responds:

Thanks very much for the review! It means alot coming from you. I hadn't really thought of a creative title or put much effort into it I focused more on the animation. I have used flash but that was a year ago. I hope I can get the full version soon.

[turnips 4 the sprites]

Dude

The sprite animation isn't the whole problem, the main reason why sprites are losing popularity is because they offer the same shit. Same jokes, same battles without reason, same crossovers with Dragon Ball Z, same sounds from shows and sitcoms.
thats why the sprite animation is losing terrain here.
As for the flash, it was very well animated for a quickie. Brian still kinda looks like if he was hand drawn, I mean, It's not pixelated enough to be considered a sprite, but well, it's just my opinion.
Nice job to you :)
Conclusion: Good :)
5/5
10/10
5/5

Voting details:
Voted 5: 3.17 / 5.00 (+ 0.035)

Note: If you really want to save sprites try to make a truly sprite animation, I highly recommend you using VG sprites (mario, asmus, link, etc) Just like you did in your flash of mario :)

***Pigeonmaster88***

[How To: Win a Daily]

HAHAHAHAHAHAHA!!!

Just because the idea was hilarious and the whole animation too, you guys get my 10 and my 5, I don't remember when was the last time I laughed so hard!
Conclusion: ROFL!
10/10
5/5

voting details:
Voted 5: 3.81 / 5.00 (+ 0.0014)

Note: Thanks for giving me a nice laugh, guys!
Note 2: I favorited this! XD

***Pigeonmaster88***

Little-Renastair responds:

Hey that's great, glad you liked it :)

[OMG! SMB Mishaps!]

I watched the part 2 first...

It was way better than this, but still, was OK.
Your animation skills are amazing, and this flash is from 2006. I loved the idea of reviving some of the old ideas (but great) of Randy, was very good. But however, was not original. Don't take it bad either, I say you did an amazing job.
I'm pretty sure that someone told you this before, though :/
Conclusion: Nice :)
8/10
4/5

Voting details:
Voted 4: 4.07 / 5.00 (- 0.000056)

Note: Fuck all the sprite haters, OK? ;)

***Pigeonmaster88***

Golden-Fox responds:

Yeah, for a long time, I've been very aware of the fact that this flash was a major clitché. But hey, we make mistakes, and aside from all of that, I got a Daily 5th out of it, my first award.

Thanks for the review.

[Untitled Mario Movie]

Sorry but...

The only scene that made me laugh was when yoshi ate the fruit that luigi was trying to get. However the animation was nicely done and the quality was OK, not great but OK.
But what boils my piss is the scene number 2. For the love of God, using sounds from sitcoms or movies are not original and stopped being funny years ago.
Also you took the sound of luigi saying "Awww fuck!" from a flash from Randy Solem. But well you have all the right to use it since he didn't copyright it hehe.
7/10
4/5

Voting details:
Voted 4: 3.43 / 5.00 (+ 0.011)

Note: I mean it, DO NOT use soundclips from movies and sitcoms.

***Pigeonmaster88***

mad-dave responds:

Its from the movie the Dark Knight, It came out last month, How is that old?