ThePigeonMaster's movie Reviews on Newgrounds

[HOSUE [sic]]

Weird...

But sickly funny at the same time. I never thought of seeing Mindy again in this flash, though. The art was very good and the movement of the characters, their expressions and their voices were nicely done but again, it was very weird :/
Although this is the 1st flash which I see Dr. house in it and I really like that show.
Conclusion: Weird but Okay.
7/10
4/5

Voting details:
voting power: 7.09
voter number: 281
voted 4: 4.04 / 5.00 (+ 0.011)

Note: I can't wait to see Mindy learns a moral 2 :D

***Pigeonmaster88***

[Mario Cut Scenes 4]

Holy fuck!!!

I was lurking on the flash portal when I was this!! THIS!! The part number 4 of mario cut scenes! I can't believe you decided to make a 4!I'm a big fan of your mario cut scene series :D
But enough, let's talk about the flash. What I really liked about it, it was the originaluity it had to offer. However putting a part about a dane cook audio is not very original but since it made me laugh I'll let that go.
Conclusion: Awesome sprite work dude!
10/10
5/5

voting details:
voting power: 7.07
voter number: 261
voted 5: 3.41 / 5.00 (+ 0.020)

Note: I'd love seeing a part 5 :D

***Pigeonmaster88***

[Super Mario Idiota]

*facepalm*

Sorry to say it but none of those jokes were original and funny. they were funny back in 2004-2007 when they were new and fresh but now it's just the same old stuff :(
However I'm giving you half of the stars since the animation was smooth and well made, but the jokes were HORRIBLE and OVERUSED. The mamafucker sound is not funny anymore, I used it in some of my flashes and I noticed how overused it was.
Conclusion: Meh, same old, same old...
5/10
2/5

Voting details:
Voting power: 7.04
Voter number: 208
Voted 2: 3.25 / 5.00 (+ 0.051)

Note: Animaciones como estas estan acabando con la animación en sprites, ofreciendo los mismos chistes, mismos sonidos de sitcoms, copias modificadas de otros flashes :(
Si piensas hacer una parte 2, hazlo original, y todos los que te dieron 10's en reviews es porque no han checado la gran coleccion de flashes de mario.
Lo siento, pero para la proxima se original.
Saludos desde Mexico.

***Pigeonmaster88***

[In the street]

Nice!

The best part of the flick was the ending, you definitively got me there xD
I really like your artwork a lot, it's kinds cartoon-ish which is a cool detail when making a good drawing or a simple flash animation. The song really fits in the plot and gives to the flash a comical touch.
Conclusion: Exellent flash, keep up the good work.
10/10
5/5

Voting details:
Voting power: 6.88
Voter number: 238
Voted 5: 3.83 / 5.00 (+ 0.021)

Note: I didn't find any glitches or bugs, I think it's just your computer.

Note 2: Why didn't ask me if you wanted the actionscript of an easter egg? I could have helped you since now I know more about actionscript :(

***Pigeonmaster88***

Kde777 responds:

Sorry Jimmy I just couldn't found you in the MSN (estamos hablando en ingles y tranquilamente podriamos hablar en castellano)

but it's okay because I was lookin for that bonus scene. and I realized I deleted it xD.. is just on .swf ..
OH!! I could submited a scene that's not going to be released on sonic shorts volume.. i'm stupid..

thanks jimmy, you're cool

[Super Sprite Shorts Vol 3]

*Yawn*

You know? That animation was smooth, decent and the sounds where nicely chosen, but the jokes were not funny. They weren't bad, but I've seen those jokes before EVEN without seeing, Know what I mean? If not, then watch the whole Videogame parodies collection.
The part of mario scaring everybody was predictable, I thought or bowser or a bob-omb to come to hurt mario. And a bob-omb appeared as I thought.
Conclusion: Good animation, bad jokes.
4/10
2/5

Voting details:
Voting power: 6.87
Voter number: 220
Voted 2: 3.35 / 5.00 (- 0.033)

Note: I watched Vol 1 and I lol'ed, a lot. Now I watch this and I have no words...

***Pigeonmaster88***

[FlashSaga2: Space]

Experimental flash

I think this should be classified as an experimental flash, also, the song doesn't go with the animation style but anyway, nice song XD
The animation was very detailed, from vectorial to custom sprites, I liked that.
The Frame by frame was nicely animated, whoever made those segments of FBF, my respects :)
8/10
4/5

Voting details:
Voting power: 6.87
Voter number: 228
Voted 4: 3.55 / 5.00 (+ 0.029)

Note: You're wrong, is "No me gusta ESE score" :)

***Pigeonmaster88***

[Bowser's Kingdom: Movie]

Dissapointed

What happened guys? Sorry but I was expecting something more "movie" worthy, it's just like another episode but longer.
You have no idea how much I loved the previous episodes, when I saw this in the portal as "The movie" I was excited! But it was the same thing:
- steve jokes
- lucky candy
- trying to be villians
You could have used those jokes but try to use them in a different or a new way, know what I mean?
The quality of the sound was good, but use the original soundtracks, for the love of God, it makes a sprite flash even more "game-ish".
But what boils my piss is the Mortal Kombat reference, same DBZ sound effects like in every sprite fight flash. That steals another star. That ruined the MK joke.
The animation of the sprites was decent, but you used a lot of tweens, in my opinion.
Conclusion: An OK sprite flash, but I'm dissapointed because I was expecting an epic movie.
7/10
3/5

Voting details:
Voter number: 1,178
Voting power: 6.83
Voted 3: 4.41 / 5.00 (+ 0.00085)

Note: I still liked this, don't think I hated the movie.

***Pigeonmaster88***

[Super Sprite Shorts Vol 1]

Improve your sound quality

It was somewhat nice but please use a better quality sound next time.
My favourite skit was when luigi was attacked, you got me there. The animation was pretty nice but again, the sound.
Next volume try to make it longer than just 1 minute, it would be nice.
Conclusion: Pretty nice, but work on your sound quality.
8/10
4/5

Voting details:
Voting power: 6.79
Voter number: 487
Voted 4: 3.58 / 5.00 (+ 0.0059)

Note: super sprite shorts? Did you get inspired by my friend ultramoron and his stupid sprite shorts?

***Pigeonmaster88***

R3DPhoenix responds:

Thanks for the constructive review! In response the the issue you highlighted, I agree, the sound is a bit off, but they sound fine before they are imported into Flash. If you have any ideas, I would be happy as larry if you could PM me with some suggestions. Much love.

[Yoshi's Flower]

Made me LOL

But what screws up the perfect score were some details. I can actually see the white canvas where yoshi's flying around the whole screen, in my opinion, that's a fatal mistake when making any kind of flash (sprite, drawn, sticks...).
The sound quality was awesome, but man, please learn how to stream your sounds, it makes the size of the flash smaller. And the next time (if you want), try to use the original soundtracks of the game, it makes your flash look better and more "game-ish".
Conclusion: Nice animation, made me laugh but improve more. Nice job.
7/10
4/5

Voting details:
Voting power: 6.79
Voter number: 229
Voted 4: 3.55 / 5.00 (+ 0.029)

***Pigeonmaster88***

dark-fusion1 responds:

Whoa... you're right about the white canvas. I could have sworn it was perfectly alligned though... Thanks for noticing, I'm going to edit that out now.

[Sprite A Week: 1]

You only want awards...

I can do something better than this in less than 1 week. And I can animate the same skits that were in this flash in less than 2 days...
I was the dude that told to Paperbat to do sprite a week, and I told to him:
"If I don't like it I will vote 0/10 0/5"
I don't care if Paperbat is not here but I'm still gonna be honest:

Khawner:
Oh not again... Another ripoff of JonBro's and Psycosis remakes.
And you took the other skit from another skit from the sprite a day series.
You get 0/10

Fawx:
The mama luigi meme is only funny in the forums when you see it where it can't make any sense. I didn't laugh, but the animation was decent so:
4/10

Will Ryan (diamond-armada):
Bad sprite image quality, and I didn't get the joke. Perhaps it wasn't any funny at all.
3/10

Hillbo:
Sorta funny, but not good enough. But what lowered your score was the baby mario killing himself. Think in a better ending joke next time, will you?
5/10

Davidzx:
Can I ask you something? Why did you join to this? You have A LOT of potential on being a good sprite animator. Your part was the only one that made me laugh, it was decent animated, somewhat original. The only bad thing is the fact you can see the white lines around the sprites when they're growing. Try to do something BIG by YOURSELF, just practice more and you will end being a DECENT sprite animator. But it depends IN YOU.
7/10

Conclusion:
STOP THIS! You guys are killing the sprite animation with flashes like this. I gave one chance to the sprite a week, but no... You failed, I feel ashamed on being a sprite animator.
0/10
0/5

Voting details:
Voting power: 6.79
Voter number: 230
Voted 0: 3.37 / 5.00 (- 0.033)

Note: You guys make me think in quitting sprites like many others. And to be honest, I WILL HAVE TO DO IT SOONER.

Note 2: If you make this for fun PLEASE PUT EFFORT. But I think you're still going to send to the portal the same kind of "good quality" sprite flash each week and kill the sprite animation. You are just proving to the sprite haters their points, thanks for contributing in that >:(

***Pigeonmaster88***

Khonjin responds:

I hope you remember the same exact response I gave you last time you posted this.