ThePigeonMaster's movie Reviews on Newgrounds

[Vete a la Versh 4]

Hahahahaha

Fucking hilarious! I like your drawing and animation style, your animations always put a smile on my face like always. I'm amazed on how you can turn an idea that is extremely stupid into something hilarious.
Conclusion: Congratulation man, excellent flash!
10/10
5/5

Voting details:
Voting power: 7.42
Voter number: 2498
Voted 5: 4.24 / 5.00 (+ 0.00050)

Note: I can't wait to see the 5th episode :D

***TPM***

Darkar responds:

Thanks a lot! :)

[Snow Wars Introduction]

Nice.

It seems it will be interesting, but to be honest, it won't beat hay wars (unless you make it with more "violence" :P).
I lol'ed at some parts while others caught my attention completely. I disliked the quality of the video but I'm going to be less strict with that since you put a lot of effort in the making of the movie.
Conclusion: Nice starting.
7/10
4/5

Voting details:
Voting power: 7.41
Voter number: 334
Voted 4: 3.43 / 5.00 (+ 0.011)

Note: Go for an epic movie, please ;)

***TPM***

Fro responds:

I guarantee you that the Snow Wars battle's will beet the Hay Wars battle by a long shot. Violence + Plot this time around. It's just never going to get done.

Thanks for the review.

[ElGatoViudo (TheWidowCat)]

Tatiana's version is way better

I actually grew up with Tatiana's version of "El gato viudo". But screw that, the animation was nicely done and it was mild entertaining, I liked how you used some effects in the movie such as blur, the X-ray effect and the cat sad expression.
Nothing too mind blowing but still a decent piece of flash, good!
Conclusion: OK
8/10
5/5

Voting power: 7.26
Voter number: 222
Voted 5: 3.68 / 5.00 (+ 0.030)

Note: Just because you're mexican like me you'll get my 5 in the voting score :P

***TPM***

Jectoons responds:

this is the original version. Tatiana is pop-

yay :P

[life's framerate]

Made me LOL nicely

Man, I'm glad to see that you're still making flash submissions, it looks like you've improved a lot since the last time I saw a flash of yours. It was something original and it gives a few chuckles.
Nice sound, music and voiceact quality. Well done.
The only thing that fucks up the perfect score is the quality of the image of the NG website (the part where the NG page zooms and appears a 3.32 score).
9/10
5/5

Voting details:
Voting power: 7.24
Voter number: I voted while it was UJ, no info available
Voted 5: I voted while it was UJ, no info available

Note: Keep up the good work man.

***TPM***

Khris responds:

dude, i have not herd from u in a while, glad to see your still helpin out the portal

[Meeting Friends part. 1]

Nice artwork.

The artwork really impressed me a lot. The whole comic book was pretty funny and clever but it felt really "death". That's because of the lack of sound effects in it. But if you could have made that idea in a whole animation then it would had been even better.
Still, a fine piece of work. Nice job.
Conclusion: Very good.
8/10
4/5

Voting details:
Voting power: 7.24
Voter number: 636
Voted 4: 3.69 / 5.00 (+ 0.00049)

Note: The reason of why I gave you an 8 it's because the music loops at the end of the flash. Don't forget to add this script at the very last frame of the flash movie if you set your sound as "Event":
stopAllSounds();

***TPM***

Unigodspawn responds:

mmm si me fije de eso... eso fue lo que se me olvido en la animacion n__nU pero que mas.... me da peresa modificar el archivo y volverlo a subir hehe bueno! gracias men! Xp

[Pixtropolis City]

Truly worth of a 10 and 5

Not because I was part of it, it's because the concept of the collab and the art was very interesting and entertaining. I loved how I started the whole thing in the collab :P pretty interesting. FireBlazeProductions's part was incredible and my favorite because it has an animation, art and a clever plot, well kinda.
YoungAndWise's part was also pretty neat and inspiring to all the people that want to participate in Pico's day contest :P
And to the rest, awesome job guys. Thank you mexifry for inviting me.
10/10
5/5

Voting details:
Voting power: 7.22
Voter number: I voted while it was UJ, no info available
Voted 5: I voted while it was UJ, no info available

Note: I smell frontpage for this.

***TPM***

[In the street]

Nice!

The best part of the flick was the ending, you definitively got me there xD
I really like your artwork a lot, it's kinds cartoon-ish which is a cool detail when making a good drawing or a simple flash animation. The song really fits in the plot and gives to the flash a comical touch.
Conclusion: Exellent flash, keep up the good work.
10/10
5/5

Voting details:
Voting power: 6.88
Voter number: 238
Voted 5: 3.83 / 5.00 (+ 0.021)

Note: I didn't find any glitches or bugs, I think it's just your computer.

Note 2: Why didn't ask me if you wanted the actionscript of an easter egg? I could have helped you since now I know more about actionscript :(

***Pigeonmaster88***

Kde777 responds:

Sorry Jimmy I just couldn't found you in the MSN (estamos hablando en ingles y tranquilamente podriamos hablar en castellano)

but it's okay because I was lookin for that bonus scene. and I realized I deleted it xD.. is just on .swf ..
OH!! I could submited a scene that's not going to be released on sonic shorts volume.. i'm stupid..

thanks jimmy, you're cool

[FlashSaga2: Space]

Experimental flash

I think this should be classified as an experimental flash, also, the song doesn't go with the animation style but anyway, nice song XD
The animation was very detailed, from vectorial to custom sprites, I liked that.
The Frame by frame was nicely animated, whoever made those segments of FBF, my respects :)
8/10
4/5

Voting details:
Voting power: 6.87
Voter number: 228
Voted 4: 3.55 / 5.00 (+ 0.029)

Note: You're wrong, is "No me gusta ESE score" :)

***Pigeonmaster88***

[Super Sprite Shorts Vol 1]

Improve your sound quality

It was somewhat nice but please use a better quality sound next time.
My favourite skit was when luigi was attacked, you got me there. The animation was pretty nice but again, the sound.
Next volume try to make it longer than just 1 minute, it would be nice.
Conclusion: Pretty nice, but work on your sound quality.
8/10
4/5

Voting details:
Voting power: 6.79
Voter number: 487
Voted 4: 3.58 / 5.00 (+ 0.0059)

Note: super sprite shorts? Did you get inspired by my friend ultramoron and his stupid sprite shorts?

***Pigeonmaster88***

R3DPhoenix responds:

Thanks for the constructive review! In response the the issue you highlighted, I agree, the sound is a bit off, but they sound fine before they are imported into Flash. If you have any ideas, I would be happy as larry if you could PM me with some suggestions. Much love.

[Yoshi's Flower]

Made me LOL

But what screws up the perfect score were some details. I can actually see the white canvas where yoshi's flying around the whole screen, in my opinion, that's a fatal mistake when making any kind of flash (sprite, drawn, sticks...).
The sound quality was awesome, but man, please learn how to stream your sounds, it makes the size of the flash smaller. And the next time (if you want), try to use the original soundtracks of the game, it makes your flash look better and more "game-ish".
Conclusion: Nice animation, made me laugh but improve more. Nice job.
7/10
4/5

Voting details:
Voting power: 6.79
Voter number: 229
Voted 4: 3.55 / 5.00 (+ 0.029)

***Pigeonmaster88***

dark-fusion1 responds:

Whoa... you're right about the white canvas. I could have sworn it was perfectly alligned though... Thanks for noticing, I'm going to edit that out now.